The Dog
Except for the dog, that she wouldn’t have him put away, wouldn’t let him die, I’d have liked her.
She was handsome, busty, chunky, early middle-aged, very black, with a stiff, exotic dignity
that flurried up in me a mix of warmth and sexual apprehension neither of which, to tell the truth,
I tried very hard to nail down: she was that much older and in those days there was still the race thing.
This was just the time of civil rights: the neighbourhood I was living in was mixed.
In the narrow streets, the tiny three-floored houses they called father-son-holy-ghosts
which had been servants’ quarters first, workers’ tenements, then slums, still were, but enclaves of us,
beatniks and young artists, squatted there and commerce between everyone was fairly easy.
Her dog, a grinning mongrel, rib and knob, gristle and grizzle, wasn’t terribly offensive.
The trouble was that he was ill, or the trouble more exactly was that I had to know about it.
She used to walk him on a lot I overlooked, he must have had a tumor of a blockage of some sort
because every time he moved his bowels, he shrieked, a chilling, almost human scream of anguish.
It nearly always caught me unawares, but even when I’d see them first, it wasn’t better.
The limp leash coiled in her hand, the woman would be profiled to the dog, staring into the distance,
apparently oblivious, those breasts of hers like stone, while he, not a step away, labouring,
trying to eject the feeble, mucus-coated, blood-flecked chains that finally spurted from him,
would set himself on tiptoe and hump into a question mark, one quivering back leg grotesquely lifted.
Every other moment he’d turn his head, as though he wanted her, to no avail, to look at him,
then his eyes would dim and he’d drive his wounded anus in the dirt, keening uncontrollably,
lurching forward in a hideous, electric dance as though someone were at him with a club.
When at least he’d finish, she’d wipe him with a tissue like a child; he’d lick her hand.
It was horrifying; I was always going to call the police; once I actually went out to chastise her –
didn’t she know how selfish she was, how the animal was suffering? – she scared me off, though.
She was older than I’d thought, for one thing, her flesh was loosening, pouches of fat beneath the eyes,
and poorer, too, shabby, tarnished: I imagined smelling something faintly acrid as I passed.
Had I ever really mooned for such a creature? I slunk around the block, chagrined, abashed.
I don’t recall them too long after that. Maybe the dog died, maybe I was just less sensitive.
Maybe one year when the cold came and I closed my windows, I forgot them … then I moved.
Everything was complicated now, so many tensions, so much bothersome self-consciousness.
Anyway, those back streets, especially in bad weather when the ginkgos lost their leaves, were bleak.
It’s restored there now, ivy, pointed brick, garden walls with broken bottles mortared on them,
but you’d get sick and tired then: the rubbish in the gutter, the general sense of dereliction.
Also, I’d found a girl to be in love with: all we wanted was to live together, so we did.
About this poem
Ruth Padel came to the Scottish Poetry Library in November 2007, and talked about a poem by C. K. Williams and a poem of her own. She commented on the two poems:
All too often, judging a poetry competition, you read a poem which has lovely lines, lovely apercus, nice cadences and all that, but the poet throws it away in the last two lines. It doesn't know where it's going, and "going" is what poems are about. It is the movement through that you remember, and which reveals the structure of thought. A poem is many different journeys – of sound, sense and image – braiding into one and all brought together at the end.
So movement was what I wanted to concentrate on and I chose long poems because you can feel the movement through them very clearly. Besides, people often feel put off by long poems so I thought someone walking beside might help.
Ruth Padel writes about 'The Dog' by C. K. Williams:
The work of the American poet C. K. Williams is driven by compassion, self-doubt about the poet's moral and mental processes, and passionate attention to the world. He has developed a beautifully cadenced long line and his control of this line, but also narrative, angle and voice is fantastic. His work is both political (or if you like social) and personal.
This is a poem about growing up. Its journey is partly through the senses – it begins with I and her (I'd have liked her) – because this is a journey into exploring how the I grew up, via how he felt about her.
The first sense is sight. The woman is seen from a window like a statue, chunky, stiff. Apart from being herself, in the dog drama we are going to watch with the poet, she represents "the other" – female to his male, exotic, alone, very black; while he is not only an I but a we of young artists. And there is still the race thing.
The ninth line begins the next section, picking up the dog from the first line. The trouble (here comes this poet's characteristic refining of honesty, the self doubt, the self criticalness): that I had to know about its suffering.
After vision, sound. The scream of anguish becomes a keening: a very human and archaic, mourning. That dog is becoming an image for all suffering, human included. Then comes taste and touch (lick her hand) and smell (smelling something faintly acrid) – and the poet ashamed of his own feelings: chagrined, abashed.
In the new section, he has lost interest and memory: I don't recall them. He is growing up (maybe I was just less sensitive), and maybe (he wonders) he might have closed a window or two in the process.
The last section gives us the time frame - enough years for a derelict neighbourhood to be restored; though the broken bottles mortared on walls suggests social walls such as that implied between the I and the her, have not been ironed out. This reprises those tenements or slums. The neighbourhood he called mixed is revisited in memory as bleak. And this far-off growing-up period was really a point of focussing on his own life, not on animal suffering. He found a girl to be in love with – not "fell in love" but, with more of that bothersome self consciousness, he represents himself as waiting for this.
The language is partly (but gently, obliquely) self-critical. It suggests that one (not necessarily admirable) part of growing up is seeing suffering, trying to do something about it, but in the end allowing your own concerns to take priority. The ending replaces I with we. The poem seemed at first to be about the woman and her dog, the title noun, whose suffering stands in for all the suffering you see (and are going to see in your life) from the window of the self. But the ending shows it is really about the growing up of I.
Ruth Padel © 2007