The Thursday Post: Poems That Make PEOPLE Cry
1 May 2014

selbstinszinierung durch fremdbestimmung by der bobbel, under a Creative Commons licence
I keep hearing about the anthology Poems That Make Grown Men Cry. Someone mentioned it in a meeting, and my partner sent me a Richard Dawkins tweet about the launch at the National Theatre – quite a list of names at that event: Melvyn Bragg, Richard Dawkins, Ian McEwan, Richard Eyre, Mike Leigh, Simon McBurney, Ben Okri, Simon Russell Beale and Simon Schama.
The thing is, I’m torn about this sort of anthology. On the one hand, I think it’s fabulous that poetry is being highlighted in such a high profile way and I totally understand that the concept is a goer – easy to market, easy to sell.
What rubs me the wrong way about it, however, is how it seems to click right in to a whole set of stereotypes about men and the role of men in society. A friend turned me on to the provocative and inspiring writing of bell hooks recently and immersing myself in her fascinating books has meant that the way our patriarchal society damages people, both male and female, has been very much on my mind. It is disturbing to realise how intrinsic patriarchal thinking is in our everyday lives – so much so that we often don’t even notice the ways that we are engaging with it and supporting it, women included.
The copy on the publisher’s website states:
‘GROWN MEN AREN'T SUPPOSED TO CRY. But in this fascinating anthology, one hundred men – distinguished in literature and film, science and architecture, theatre and human rights – confess to being moved to tears by poems that haunt them.’
So on the one hand I’m gratified that this book is saying actually, grown men do cry – and is getting them to talk about their emotions on a very public platform. But I worry about double messages – for instance, imagine using the headline ‘children hate poetry’ to provoke people into reading an article about why children actually like poetry. What message is being sent? Like the advertising copy for the launch, but more indirectly, the title of this book refers to and echoes that old phrase ‘Grown Men Don’t Cry’ and potentially emphasises the patriarchal tropes that have caused men and women so much pain. Is the title saying that normal grown men don’t cry, but poetry’s exceptional power is to make them cry…?
What is worse, to my mind, is the fact that this anthology – in the guise of celebrating male emotion – highlights and promotes, in isolation, the ideas of 100 distinguished MEN.
Poetry, like most other businesses, has long been dominated by men: the well-known poets, the published poets, the critically acclaimed poets, the critics, the editors, the publishers, and so on – predominantly, traditionally male. In fact, have a look at the table of contents and see how many of the poems selected in this anthology are written by women. I would argue that this in no way reflects the number of talented women throughout the ages who could have and would have made extraordinary contributions to the literary world and beyond had they existed in a society that supported their, especially intellectual, activities in equal measure to their male counterparts. It is a great boost to female writers – and readers – to see that the current poets laureate of the UK, Scotland, Wales and Belfast are women.
I absolutely do think we should talk more about male emotion, but I also think women should be involved in the conversation. I understand there is a plan to follow this book with a similar collection for women – but why separate them? Why bring out one first, the one featuring men, and then the other? Financial implications may play some part, but it is in all our interests for companies to get better at making decisions that take into account the impact on society (socially, environmentally, et cetera) as well as their own financial well-being.
In an article on The Guardian website, one of the editors of the anthology, Anthony Holden, says: ‘One of our main aims is obviously to encourage more people to read poetry, to which our contributors' potent introductions offer an open door; once you have read them, you cannot help but read the poems themselves. Given that so many of these men are internationally admired, we also hope that schools will find this a handy new way to hook their pupils on poetry.’
And while I completely agree that poetry should have a more prominent place in school curriculums, I wince at the thought that another generation of children could grow up believing that it’s what men think about poetry that matters most.
I’d prefer to see more balanced approaches to publishing, which by their very design are countering, rather than reinforcing, damaging stereotypes and patterns of behaviour. I’m glad that poetry can make men cry. I believe that it can make all people cry, and laugh, and sing.
Jennifer Williams
Programme Manager
Poems That Make Grown Men Cry